Football and rugby are two of the most popular team sports played around the world. They share a common origin, particularly when we look at the evolution of football, especially American football, and how it was influenced by rugby. Many people are curious about the relationship between football and rugby, specifically asking if football is based on rugby. To answer this, we need to examine their histories, the development of the rules, and how the two sports diverged into the distinct games we know today.
While both football and rugby originated from similar games played in the British Isles during the 19th century, the path that each sport took was influenced by various factors, including culture, geography, and the development of new rules. This article explores how football and rugby evolved, the extent to which football is based on rugby, and the differences that make these two sports unique today.
The Origins of Football and Rugby
Early Versions of Football
Before football and rugby became the standardized sports we know today, they were played as forms of folk games in schools and villages across Britain. These games typically involved groups of people, sometimes hundreds, trying to carry or kick a ball toward a designated area, such as a goal or a specific landmark. The rules were unclear, varied from region to region, and there were no formalized systems for play. This form of football (soccer) was commonly played in public schools, especially in England.
At the same time, in some schools, particularly Rugby School in Warwickshire, the game began to take a more defined shape. Rugby School is credited with being the birthplace of the game of rugby football, which became distinct from other versions of football through its inclusion of carrying the ball and the specific tackling rules.
Rugby Football’s Development
Rugby football was formalized in the early 19th century at Rugby School, where it diverged from other versions of football played in England. The school’s version allowed players to carry the ball, an element that was not present in the other versions of football at the time, such as association football (soccer). The game’s development continued at Rugby School, and in 1871, the Rugby Football Union (RFU) was established to create unified rules for the game.
This development laid the foundation for rugby as a distinct sport. The rules included methods for passing the ball, scrums, and tackling, which set rugby apart from other football codes. Over time, the sport spread to other parts of the world, particularly in countries like New Zealand, South Africa, Australia, and France.
The Emergence of Association Football (Soccer)
In contrast to rugby, the early form of association football, or soccer, did not allow players to carry the ball. In the mid-19th century, a group of schools and clubs in England began working together to formalize the rules of football. In 1863, the Football Association (FA) was founded, and a set of standardized rules was developed. These rules prohibited carrying the ball, making football distinct from rugby.
As a result, association football (or soccer) began to evolve into the game we know today, where players use their feet to control the ball and attempt to score goals by kicking the ball into the opposing team’s net.
The Connection Between Football and Rugby
Shared Origins
The early versions of both football and rugby were played under similar circumstances, with minimal formal rules. As mentioned earlier, these games were often played in public schools in England and involved a mix of kicking, carrying, and handling the ball. The influence of Rugby School, where the game of rugby was first developed, played a significant role in shaping the early rules of both rugby and football.
In fact, early football (soccer) players and rugby players were, in many cases, part of the same community of players. It wasn’t until later that the two sports started to split based on rule changes.
The fundamental difference between the two early games was how the ball was used. While the game of rugby allowed for running with the ball in hand, football (soccer) prohibited this. This created a natural distinction between the two sports that has remained ever since.
How Rugby Influenced Early American Football
The story of American football’s development is closely tied to rugby, particularly in the late 19th century. American football evolved out of rugby and a variant of football played in American colleges. In the mid-1800s, colleges such as Harvard, Princeton, and Yale began playing a form of football that included elements of both rugby and association football. This was the beginning of what would later become American football.
One of the key figures in the development of American football was Walter Camp, who is often referred to as the “father of American football.” Camp played a significant role in the creation of many of the rules that distinguish American football from rugby, such as the concept of downs, the creation of the line of scrimmage, and the formation of teams on the field. Although these changes were designed to create a distinct game, they were still rooted in the principles of rugby and early football.
The Spread of Rugby and American Football
As rugby continued to develop in countries like New Zealand and South Africa, it began to differentiate itself further from the early forms of football. The global popularity of rugby led to the formation of international competitions, most notably the Rugby World Cup. Meanwhile, in the United States, American football continued to evolve and eventually became the national pastime, thanks in part to its links to rugby.
Today, rugby is played primarily in countries like England, France, New Zealand, and South Africa, while American football has gained immense popularity in the United States, Canada, and parts of Mexico. Despite their shared ancestry, the two sports have developed into entirely separate games with their own traditions and styles of play.
The Differences Between Football and Rugby
1. The Ball
One of the most obvious differences between football and rugby is the shape of the ball. In rugby, the ball is oval-shaped and designed for both passing and carrying. The unique shape allows players to carry the ball in one hand or both hands and pass it backward to teammates.
In contrast, the ball in football (soccer) is round and primarily intended for kicking and controlling with the feet. This round ball makes passing, dribbling, and shooting a central part of the game. The difference in ball shape is reflective of the differing objectives and strategies in each sport.
2. The Field and Players
Football and rugby also differ in terms of the field size and the number of players on each team. A standard football field is usually around 100 yards long and 50 to 60 yards wide, with 11 players on each team. The field is marked by a series of lines, including a center line and penalty areas.
In rugby, the field is similar in size, but the number of players on each team varies depending on the code being played. In rugby union, there are 15 players per team, while in rugby league, there are only 13. Rugby fields are also marked with different lines, including those for scrums, lineouts, and conversions.
3. Scoring
The methods of scoring in football and rugby are another significant difference. In football, players score by kicking the ball into the opposing team’s goal. This goal can be scored in various ways, such as from a header, a kick, or a volley. Points are awarded for goals, and the team with the most goals at the end of the match wins.
In rugby, scoring is achieved through a combination of tries, conversions, penalty kicks, and drop goals. A try is scored when a player touches the ball down over the opponent’s goal line. After a try, the team has the opportunity to kick a conversion to score additional points. Penalty kicks and drop goals can also contribute to the final score.
4. Contact and Physicality
Rugby is a much more physically demanding sport than football, as players are allowed to tackle opponents in many situations. In rugby, tackling is an essential part of the game, and players can use their body to block or bring down opponents. The physicality of rugby also extends to scrums and lineouts, where players engage in close-quarters competition for the ball.
Football, on the other hand, is less focused on contact. While some physicality exists in football, especially in challenges for the ball, players are not permitted to tackle opponents in the same way as in rugby. The emphasis in football is on skillful ball control, passing, and positioning.
5. Substitutions and Game Time
Football matches are typically 90 minutes long, divided into two 45-minute halves. Teams are allowed three substitutions per game, though there are variations depending on the competition. In contrast, rugby matches last 80 minutes (two 40-minute halves) and allow a greater number of substitutions. The faster pace of rugby also makes it more physically demanding, which influences the frequency of substitutions.
Conclusion
While football and rugby share a common origin, the two sports have evolved in distinct ways over the centuries. Football, particularly association football (soccer), is not based on rugby; however, both sports have historical connections and similar roots in early forms of folk football. The development of rugby led to the creation of a sport with a focus on carrying and tackling the ball, while football emphasized the use of feet to control the ball.
American football, which evolved from rugby in the United States, shares more similarities with rugby than soccer does, but still differs significantly in its rules and style of play. Ultimately, both sports have their unique characteristics, and while they share some common history, football and rugby remain separate and distinct games, each with its own appeal and traditions.
Related Topics
- Can I Be Skinny and Play Rugby
- Are There 15 Players in a Rugby Team
- Where Is the Rugby League World Cup Final
